• Home
  • US Politics
  • Business & Economy
  • UK & Welsh Politics
  • Reflections On...
  • Video Archive
Reflections On

Gwen Ifill’s Book Makes Her Impartial? - Much Ado About Nothing

Posted on 03 October 2008 by Sharon Kyle

 

PBS' Gwen Ifill

by Sharon Kyle

All this talk on Fox News about Gwen Ifill’s objectivity being compromised because she has a soon to be released book entitled, “Breakthrough: Politics and Race in the Age of Obama” sounds a lot like much ado about nothing.

I did a little searching and found that PBSs Jim Lehrer, moderator of several consecutive presidential debates dating back twenty years is quite a prolific author. According to Amazon.com, Jim Lehrer has authored at least 17 novels. In fact, his newest release, “Mack to the Rescue (Stories and Storytellers)” was released in hardcover in May 2008. Although fictional, it is a political satire that pokes fun of such things as privatization.

In September 2000, Lehrer’s book “The Last Debate” was released. This too, is a fictional account of a debate where, according to Amazon.com, the “Republican is a born-again racist, while the Democrat is not too swift but a decent fellow.”

Tom Brokaw’s book, “Boom!: Talking About the Sixties: What Happened, How It Shaped Today, Lessons for Tomorrow” will be released in paperback on Oct 14, 2008 according to Amazon. The editorial review says of the book , “it is held together by Brokaw’s own biographical time line and opinions.”

It’s common for journalists to author books. Their personal opinions may come through in the text. This does not render them incapable of remaining any more or any less objective during a debate than they would have been had they not written a book. It is preposterous to put forward the idea that journalists can’t do their jobs because they have their own personal opinions.

The table below contains a list of debate moderators from 2008 through 1988.

2008   1st-Jim Lehrer   2nd- Tom Brokaw        3rd-Bob Schieffer     VP Gwen Ifill
2004   1st-Jim Lehrer   2nd-Charles Gibson    3rd-Bob Schieffer      VP Gwen Ifill
2000   1st-Jim Lehrer   2nd-Jim Lehrer            3rd-Jim Lehrer           VP Bernard Shaw
1996   1st-Jim Lehrer   2nd-Jim Lehrer            VP Jim Lehrer
1992   1st-Jim Lehrer   2nd-Carole Simpson   3rd-Jim Lehrer           VP Hal Bruno
1988   1st-Jim Lehrer   2nd-Bernard Shaw       VP Judy Woodruff

Source: Commission on Presidential Debates
Note: There were only two presidential debates in 1996 and 1988

The Fox News’ assertion that Gwen Ifill is biased is an absurd ploy to get more buzz going about Palin and possibly give the right an excuse for Palin’s inevitably poor perfomance at tonight’s debate.

Share and Enjoy:

These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Mixx

Sharon Kyle is Publisher of the LA Progressive. With her husband Dick, she publishes several other print and online newsletters on political and social justice issues. In addition to her work at JPL, Sharon is enrolled in law school at the People's College of Law in Los Angeles. She is also the mother of two adult children, Wade and Deva and the step-mother to two children, Raheem and Linnea.
Email this author | All posts by Sharon Kyle

Comments are closed.

Saturday, 4th July 2009



Live Political Twitter Feed

Wilderness Dispatches

facebook-friends Wiley and Non Squitur cuts too close to the quick for many.

Advertisers

Follow and Bookmark us






Bookmark and Share

Tags

Al Gore BBC Bill Clinton Charley James clinton CNN David Cameron democratic party democrats Denis Campbell Dick Cheney FOX FOX News George Bush George W. Bush Georgia GOP Gordon Brown Iraq Joe Biden John McCain Karl Rove Keith Olbermann London McCain MSNBC NBC New York Times obama Palin President Obama Republicans Rush Limbaugh Sarah Palin super delegates Tesco The Netherlands Tony Blair Tories Twitter UK vadimus post Wales White House Yahoo!

WP Cumulus Flash tag cloud by Roy Tanck requires Flash Player 9 or better.



Friends

LA ProgressiveProPublica
Divazzy
Grainger and Whitney
Panoramic TVCambria Politico

Contributors

Dr Anthony Asadullah SamadCarl MatthesCharley JamesDavid Swanson
Denis CampbellDick PriceDorret Groot WassinkKevin Lynn
Madeleine Begun KaneMonroe AndersonMarcus SternMark leVine
Robert ReichRev. Monroe AndersonSherwood RossSharon Kyle

Links

BBC NewsCambria PoliticoThe Colbert Report
Countdown with keith OlbermenCSpanDenis Campbell : An American In Wales
Energy Grid MagazineThe GuardianLAProgressive
Mad Kane’s Political Madness
Monroe AndersonThe Huffington Post
The IndependantJamie & LouiseMad Kane
MSNBCNew York Times OnlineProgressive Curmudgeon
The Daily ShowTED.com - Ideas Worth SpreadingThe Telegraph
ViaMichelinWall Street Journal

Browse Archives


About The UKProgressive

UK Progressive E-Magazine began during the 2008 US Presidential Campaign and was created to consolidate and replace two blogs created in 2006 called “Outside the Boundaries,” a political blog and “Fire the Guru!” an expose blog of charlatans in the Mind Body Spirit business. It was briefly called The Vadimus Post. That name came from the Latin 'Quo Vadimus' or 'Where Are We Headed?'

When looking for pithy Latin URL names, I’d watched a moving episode of the same name (different tense, Quo Vadis) from Sports Night, an early series created by The West Wing’s Aaron Sorkin. It was the last episode and focused on the sale of the network to an unknown billionaire who asked the question every day of those who worked closest to him. He wanted to know the answer and… Do We Know Why? His rationale: we spend so much time on things urgent, we miss the important and do we ask ourselves (and others) why we are heading in a particular direction?

Well that is what we ask in these Op-Ed pieces, articles, live feeds, video segments and contributions from friends and affiliates. We are blessed to be able to dialogue with you and our aim is to provide independent, critical insight into the issues of the day. UK Progressive is published daily in Monknash, South Wales. Its founder, An American in Wales, is US journalist Denis Campbell who has been based in The Netherlands and the UK the last 11-years.

The opinions expressed are those of each contributor and do not represent the opinion of Denis Campbell (unless expressly authored by him), our advertisers, any related companies and/or their affiliates. This website is copyright protected by various submitting authors, is reproduced with their permission and we operate under a Creative Commons licence that allows for our content to be re-published for non-commercial, non-derivative use, without editing, or changing and that credit be provided to UK Progressive with a track back URL and, where specified, the individual writer's website link. Thank you and welcome.

Donate


UK Progressive is a free, continuously improving news distribution service (because none of us could live with ourselves or face our mothers if every edition did not represent our very best effort). A lot of work goes daily into producing this true labour of love.

While most of us have other day jobs to eat, we’d love to get to the point where we can monetize this so it covers all of our expenses, allows us to pay our contributors for their fine work and helps us to continue to expand and grow. While not like PBS or other media groups shilling for logo umbrellas every ten minutes, we find it embarrassing to even have to ask… and we could use your help.

If you like what you see here and would like to help us bring it to you by making a donation to support future developments, well, we’d really appreciate it. Our PayPal account is named after a lovely canal side café in Lochem, The Netherlands which our office overlooked years ago.

We promise a team cheer and ‘happy dance’ in your name in advance. Thanks.



License


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.0 UK: England & Wales License.


Copyright 2009 UKProgressive     Contact Us | About Us | Terms and ConditionsWebsite by Divazzy | Branding by Grainger and Whitney | Video Production by Panoramic TV | EversonNews Theme by Everson